The Best and Worst Dog Food Brands

All caring owners want to make sure their dog is getting everything he needs from healthy nutrition.

But with hundreds of pet food options on supermarket shelves, in pet stores and online, from dry and hypoallergenic dog food to raw dog food, it can be hard to know what to buy. .

We’ve made that decision a little easier by ranking the most popular dog foods according to our members.

For the first time, we questioned 2,594 Which one? members on their dog food to find out the best and worst brands for customer satisfaction.

Find the results in our customer-rated dog food brands in the table below.

Which brand of dog food is the best?

The opinion of the British Veterinary Association is that any pet food commercially manufactured in the UK that meets PFMA (Pet Food Manufacturing Association) guidelines would have full nutritional requirements for pets.

So as long as you buy a complete commercial pet food, your dog gets what he needs and you don’t need to supplement with anything else.

The results of our survey below highlight which one? members’ favorite pet food brands (ranked by customer score). We also asked them to rate value for money and whether they slightly agreed or strongly agreed with these statements:

  1. they noticed a difference in their dog’s coat
  2. their pet eats the food all at once
  3. their dog shows excitement while preparing food
  4. the bowl is always licked empty.

Customer rated dog food brands

In addition to ratings for individual aspects, we’ve given each brand an overall customer score, based on overall customer satisfaction and the likelihood of recommending it.

If you want to know the score of your dog food or are interested in the best performing brand, check out the table below.

If you are not yet a member, join Which one? to get instant access.

Which popular dog food is the cheapest?

Different package sizes and different serving size recommendations make it difficult to determine how much dog food is really costing you each month.

We compared the monthly cost of the three most popular dog food brands, as well as the best and worst brands in our survey.

Costs are based on a medium sized dog (10kg), such as a French Bulldog, and a medium large dog (20kg), such as a Border Collie, on a simple dry diet.

Here is a general overview comparing the monthly costs between burns, Royal Canin, Harrington, Bakers, and Hill dog food.

Medium and large dogs: monthly food costs

If you are not yet a member, join Which one? to get instant access.

How do I know if my dog’s food is healthy?

According to Andrew Miller, Pet Nutritionist at Premier Nutrition, “As long as a commercial food (whether dry, wet, frozen, raw, boutique, grain-free, etc.) is nutritionally complete, it is designed to provide everything a pet needs to stay healthy. Some pets have specific nutritional needs based on clinically identified issues and should be fed diets tailored to their needs under veterinary supervision.

PFMA’s Nicola Paley adds; “All ‘complete’ pet foods must, by law, contain all of the nutrients in the correct proportions that an animal needs for healthy bodily function.”

Whether you choose grain-free dog food, raw dog food, hypoallergenic dog food, or just plain kibble, commercial-grade dog food that meets PFMA guidelines is nutritionally sound. You can check on the PFMA website to find out if the manufacturer of your pet food brand is a member.

Beyond that, it comes down to your pet’s taste and how much you’re willing to spend.

What matters is how much food you feed your canine companion, as pet obesity is increasing rapidly.

empty silver pet food bowl

Is my dog ​​overweight?

Pet obesity is the number one welfare concern for veterinarians. According to The Kennel Club, between 30% and 60% of dogs are now overweight.

Daniella Dos Santos from the British Veterinary Association (BVA) told us that “Obesity is a serious health and welfare issue for companion animals and we know that more and more veterinary practices are seeing animals in overweight walking through their doors with weight-related issues such as musculoskeletal disorders”. , respiratory problems and diabetes.

She adds that “it is essential that owners understand how to recognize healthy body shape, which can be a more useful way of telling if your pet is overweight rather than relying on weight alone.” We advise owners to seek advice from their veterinarian on nutrition, exercise and how to recognize healthy body condition.

See our overview of best head torches to walk your dog in the dark.

Check your dog’s weight

Very thin – more than 20% below ideal body weight

  • Easily visible ribs, spine, and hip bones (in short-haired animals)
  • Obvious loss of muscle mass
  • No fat can be felt under the skin

Underweight – 10-20% below ideal body weight

  • Easily visible ribs, spine and hip bones
  • Obvious waistline and abdominal crease
  • Very little fat can be felt under the skin


  • Ribs, spine and hip bones feel easily
  • Visible waist and abdominal tuck
  • A small amount of fat can be felt

Overweight – 10-15% above ideal body weight

  • Ribs, spine, and hip bones are hard to feel
  • Barely visible waist with wide back
  • Layer of fat on belly and base of tail

Obese – more than 15% above ideal body weight

  • Ribs, spine and hip bones extremely hard to feel under a thick layer of fat
  • No waist is visible and the belly may sag significantly
  • Thick fat pads on lower back and base of tail
spaniel dog with an empty plastic dog food bowl

Is my dog ​​obese? Spot the signs

The Kennel Club suggests looking for:

  • A bigger, rounder face
  • A reluctance to walk
  • Difficulty walking
  • Get out of breath easily
  • A thick, fat neck
  • The ribs cannot be easily felt if you run your hands along their side
  • Obvious lack of size

If you think your furry friend might be overweight, book a visit with your local vet for advice and a plan of action.

How much should I give my dog?

Be sure to feed your pooch the right amount by measuring each meal on a scale. A few extra pieces of kibble might not seem like a lot, but it can contribute massively to weight gain.

“Our survey showed that 59% of dog owners always measure their dog food”

Most commercial dog foods come with feeding guidelines on the package based on your dog’s weight and activity levels. If you’re ever unsure, ask your veterinarian.

Your veterinarian will be able to advise you on how often you should feed your dog, depending on his individual needs.

How to choose the right dog food

Here’s what the animal charity PDSA suggests you look for and what to avoid when choosing the right dog food.

To look for:

  • Something appropriate for your dog’s age (eg puppy, adult, senior)
  • A commercial dog food labeled as “complete”
  • A manufacturer that is part of the Pet Food Manufacturer’s Association (PFMA)

To avoid:

  • Table scraps and human food as they can unbalance your dog’s diet
  • Giving your dog bones as they can cause blockages and injure your dog

1. toxic dog food

  1. artificial sweetener
  2. Alcohol
  3. Lawyers
  4. Caffeine
  5. Chocolate
  6. Fried and fatty foods
  7. Garlic and onions
  8. Grapes and raisins
  9. Nuts
  10. Milk, cream and cheese

Five key things to remember when feeding your dog

  1. Protein is one of the most important food groups, coming from meat or grains in pet food. Protein levels in wet dog food appear to be lower than in dry dog ​​food due to their high water content.
  2. However, if you feed your dog the recommended amounts of a complete wet food, he should get a daily protein intake similar to what he would get from dry food.
  3. Ingredients on the package are listed in order of quantity, so if meat is at the top of the list, it means the product contains more meat than any other ingredient.
  4. If the front of the package mentions a type of meat or any other food, such as rice or vegetables, the ingredient list must indicate the amount that is actually in the food. So a “beef and veg” dog food should tell you what percentage of beef and veggies it is made of.
  5. Do not overfeed your pet; Measure food to make sure you are giving the right amount and limit treats.

Find out how much to feed your dog and other popular questions vets have answered by going to our guide to how to choose the best dog and cat food.

dog lying on the ground looking up

Which? dog food survey

Which? Customer scores are based on overall customer satisfaction with the brand and whether or not they would recommend it.

To find out which are the best and worst dog food brands, in August 2019 we polled 4,684 people. members who recently purchased pet food and asked about their experiences with their chosen brand. More than two thousand five hundred of them owned dogs.

If you’re considering buying new dog food, check out our guide to choose a pet food for the latest tips.

For more details on the top-bought brands above, check out our reviews of Royal Canin, Harrington, Hill, burns and Bakers.

Related: Find it best dog harnesses.

Source link

Comments are closed.